Last week Jaime Maussan the Mexican UFOlogist revealed under oath at the Mexican Congress two boxes containing little Aliens. The unboxing event went viral across the World and once again stoked the ‘We Are Not Alone’ debate.

One of the Aliens unveiled by Jaime Maussan at Mexico City in Sept’23

What is lesser known is that Jaime Maussan has a history of perpetrating alien related hoaxes since 2015. This is his fourth attempt after 2015/16 & 17 attempts were proven hoaxes. The jury is still out on the current one due to ongoing investigations.

In October 1869 workers digging a well in Cardiff, New York uncovered a giant petrified man, who came to be known as the Cardiff Giant. At 10 feet and 4 inches in height and 2990 pounds in weight he was indeed a giant. As news spread across the state visitors turned up in droves and paid 50 cents each to view the giant petrified man in awe. Could this be the missing link? Actually, no! It turned out to be an elaborate hoax conceived and executed by tobacconist George Hull over the previous year. Hull spent a total of $2600 ( in 1868 Dollars ) on the giant stone statue aged with various acids and buried. In the end he made at least $23,000 on the stone statue, a return on investment of approx 9 : 1 for a one year investment. George Hull should have been a stock market player.

The Cardiff Giant (left) and cast of the skull of the Piltdown Man (right).

An even longer lasting hoax is the Piltdown Man, a paleontological fraud that lasted between 1912 and 1953 when it was definitely proven to be a fraud. The identity of the hoaxers behind this find has never been established but it is suspected that Charles Dawson a British Amatuer Archeologist was behind this fraud. Whether Dawson acted alone is uncertain, but his hunger for acclaim may have driven him to risk his reputation and misdirect the course of anthropology for decades. Turns out Dawson too had a string of hoaxes beginning 1889 until the Piltdown man discovery. The alleged missing link hoax was still very much on at the time of his death in 1916.

Jaime Maussan’s 2017 discovery of the alien corpses in Peru (and presented in 2023), close to the Nazca Lines rings similar to the Cardiff Giant & The Piltdown man.

The question of ‘ We are not alone? ‘ very much persists.

Ancient Engineering

Erich Von Daniken in his eye opening book ‘ Chariots of the Gods’ espouses the theory that primitive Man had contact with extraterrestrials over several millennia. He speaks of multiple marvels across the ancient world where there is a clear divergence between the capabilities of man and the relics left behind. Moreover the same themes come up across the World be it pyramids or flying machines or illustrations / depictions of men wearing what appear to be space helmets.

A 10,000 year old cave drawing from Chad depicting what looks like a helmeted man.

Across the world we have massive stone structures constructed, individual stones weighing in their hundreds of tons have not only been moved for hundreds of miles over land but cut and placed with extreme precision, even more mysterious the cut marks on the stone look highly machined, one possible only with present day technology.

The devastated ruins of Puma Punku, Bolivia are a great place to start. The stone ruins officially date back to AD 526 but unofficially go back 17,000 years have highly machined cuts and drill holes. The largest of the stones at Puma Punku is over 25 feet long , 17 feet wide and and three and half feet thick, the weight 131 tons. Several theories exist on how the stones were moved into place, the use of llama skins and ramps is one such theory. The precision in placing the stones brings up even more questions than answers. The stones used are andesite, diorite and granite all with a hardness quotient of over 6, the hardest stone being diamond at 10.

Examples of the stonework at Puma Punku

The dimensions of Puma Punku are 549 feet by 383 with projections of 66 feet extending to the North and South of the rectangular mound. To top the exquisite stone cutting and drilling, there is a precise stone interlocking mechanism ( much like a giant lego )that has tolerances of less than one millimetre, this certainly pushes forth the thought of an other worldly hand.

The back of an entry ticket to Puma Punku with what a reconstruction would look like.

The combination discoveries of large quantities of liquid mercury and mica at Teotihuacan begins an entire fresh line of thought and investigations. Both have no ornamental purposes ( although mercury can look like an ornamental river ). Mica is used as an insulator ( what was generating the heat at Teotihuacan?). These discoveriesd give rise to the theory Teotihuacan might have had electricity!

Any narrative on ancient engineering marvels would be incomplete without a quick mention of the Pyramid of Giza, Egypt. This highly documented structure is widely considered the most mathematically precise structure in the World. Christopher Dunn in his book Giza Power explains how the great pyramid of Giza generated power using dilute hydrochloric acid and hydrated zinc. Traces of both these elements have been found in the subterranean chambers Dunn points out to.

Christopher Dunn’s schematic of what power generation at Giza looked like.

Discoveries and theories such as these only serve to reinforce the question of what was their (the pyramids) purpose?

The Nazca Lines of Peru, geoglyphs carved into the desert floor date back to between 500 BC and 500 AD. They are negative images created in the desert floor where shallow incisions (upto 12 inches depth)were made and pebbles and rocks removed. The geoglyphs include the eagle, the hummingbird, the spider,the monkey, the sizes of these glyphs vary from just a few feet to over a 1000 feet in length. Once the size of a glyph exceeds a couple of hundred feet they have a clear perspective only from the air! Von Daniken hypotheses these glyphs were always meant as markers for air travelers. There are over a 1000 glyphs in the desert. One of the more curious glyphs on a hillside near the end of one the runways is the famous Nazca Astronaut. There are several ancient runways, the longest over 30km long, some of the lines have been created on levelled mountain peaks (the relocated rubble is completely missing) to create table tops and criss cross very much like the runways of a modern airport with various geoglyphs representing airport terminals! The theories circulating have to do with the local Indians beseeching the heavens for water. Spiders , birds and plants are water symbols and the lines head towards where the water comes from.

The Nazca Astronaut (left), Nazca Runways visible space (right).

World War II offers an interesting insight into the lines. Right after WW2 saw the birth of cargo cults on many islands in the South Pacific such as Papua New Guinea, Vanuatu, New Guinea and Solomon Islands. During the war as part of the pacific theatre American troops arrived on planes, the big, noisy, flying beasts as they constructed airfields across the primitive islands to act as both bases and launch pad for attacks on Japanese convoys. The troops arrived with a cargo of all kinds of tinned food from corned beef to peaches and other canned goodies. The Islanders who until then had always hunted or gathered their food were taken in by the food and believed the machines to be ‘ The Chariots of the Gods ‘.

The South Pacific Islanders praying to aircraft. Thus was born the Cargo Cult at the end of WW II

Once the war ended and the Americans returned home, the islanders constructed aeroplanes of wood and created shallow carved runways beseeching the Americans to return.

The most startling connection made by Von Daniken is the inscription on the sarcophagus of Lord Pakal who ruled the Mayan City of Palenque for almost 70 years upto 683 A.D.

The sarcophagus to Lord Pakal from 683 A D. Notice the nose mask, the hands looking like they are at the controls of a ship, the left foot looks like its on a pedal and rocket engine to the rear of Lord Pakal and rocket blast coming off the rocket to the right of the image.

The lid is twelve feet long and seven feet wide by nine inches thick. The stone weighs over seven tons. On the lid is a carving of Lord Pakal in what appears to be a spaceship. Pakal has a mask hooked onto his nose and hands appear to be at the controls of the craft and his left foot appears to be on a pedal. Behind Pakal is what looks like a rocket engine. Coming off the base of this craft is what look like flames that can only come off a rocket. The sarcophagus has given rise to the Mayan Astronaut theory.

UFO Conspiracy Theorist Bob Lazar and his allegations, the United States had nine flying saucers in their possession has fueled UFOlogists for over thirty years. Bob further claims he was recruited to work at facility S-4 near Area 51 facility at Groom Lake to help reverse engineer the propulsion system of the flying saucers. His claims of the facility being adjacent to Papoose Lake have been debunked by critics who point out holes in his entire education history.

This did not stop Bob from describing the propulsion system he worked on. Bob alleges the saucers had an antimatter reactor and used a stable form of a chemical element with an atomic number of 115. He said the craft appeared to bend gravity and light to travel invisibly. The element later called Moscovium was finally synthesised in 2003 and proved to be so unstable it barely lasted a few milliseconds. The properties of this element are unknown other than the fact it is very radioactive, due to its instability.

Such allegations only fuel conspiracy theories about the Roswell Incident of 1947. Officially it was a weather balloon that crashed, but conspiracy theorists insist a flying saucer crashed there and alien bodies were recovered. Roswell, New Mexico now has built a lucrative economy based on the UFO/Aliens theme!

Both the Pentagon and NASA have conducted multiple studies on UAP ( Unidentified Aerial Phenomena ) over decades and claim they have nothing to show for it, although conspiracy theorists insist this is part of a cover up. 

Scriptures from almost all religions allude to crafts and Vimanas. Dr Alexandre Petrovick Kazantsev the noted and controversial Soviet UFOlogist actually pictured a vimana from descriptions in Sanskrit from the Mahabharata.

The rocket ship as interpreted by Dr Kazantsev from the Mahabharata.

The fact is all the ancient civilizations that created these marvels of engineering have vanished leaving almost no documentation behind. The divergence between the known ability of primitive man and the engineering ability required to build on the scale they have only raises more questions than answers. 

In the absence of proof such as clear images / videos / documents available to the general public only theories abound.

The Rise of the Telescopes

Mankind has always been fascinated by the vastness of the sky. The unobstructed view of this vastness has only spurred curiosity. During the day we have this shiny orb so bright we cannot look at it directly. We have what wisps of cotton against a blue background by day that can also turn angry and dark unleashing the wrath of typhoons and hurricanes. By night we have the same vastness turn black and filled with twinkling lights. Some of them appeared to be closer to each other than others.

Mankind was in awe and scared of this vastness and had Gods named after the Sun, Moon and pretty much every type of phenomena that made its appearance. There needed to be a logical approach to this vastness. Enter the Telescope.

The inventor of the Telescope is unknown, and the earliest record of the Telescope is a patent request from 1608 in the Netherlands by Middleburg spectacle maker Hans Lipperhey for a refracting telescope.. Word of this instrument quickly spread across Europe.Galileo Galilei the pioneering Italian Astronomer made one for himself in 1609 and the name Telescope came into existence in 1611 coined by Greek astronomer Giovanni Demisiani. 

Progress of the Telescope has only furthered our understanding of the objects we observe in the sky.

The first thing that Galileo turned his telescope on was the Moon in 1609. He quickly deduced the marks we observe on the celestial body with our naked eyes were actually mountains and craters on the surface. He attempted to estimate the heights of the mountains. This excitement of observing the planets through the telescope got him to next turn his sights on Jupiter.

He noticed three fixed stars in a single line around the gas giant, all very small and totally invisible to the naked eye. They appeared fixed but actually were not and then one of them disappeared! This immediately drew him to conclude they were in fact orbiting Jupiter. A planet having smaller planets circling around it was not well received by the astronomy community of the time and raised plenty of debate.

Galileo’s next observation would pitch him directly into the face of controversy. He observed that Venus exhibited a full set of phases similar to that of the Moon and thus observed it must be orbiting the Sun! The heliocentric model of the Solar System developed by Nicholas Copernicus in the 1500s was however the lesser accepted version of the Universe to the geocentric one. The geocentric model stipulated the Earth was at the centre of the Universe as the stars rose and dipped and changed positions in the sky.

A comparison of Galileo’s observation of the rotations of Venus (left) v/s the prevailing ideas ( right) from Wikipedia.

Thus progressed astronomy with further observation of the celestial bodies closest to Earth.

Astronomers knew there was more to be discovered. Telescopes got bigger and bigger but were still Earthbound and stationed at the tops of peaks where atmospheric interference was less, Earthbound nonetheless.

The 1990 launch of the Space Telescope Hubble promised to herald a new era in Mankind’s understanding of the Cosmos. What promised to be the dawn of a new era however turned into a sci-fi space thriller. Due to a manufacturing error the main mirror on the telescope had a focus issue and to solve this NASA astronauts had to get Hubble a pair of glasses to fix the blurry images. In December 1993 Space Shuttle Endeavour went up the 340 miles into space, captured Hubble and got the issue fixed. Hubble over the years had twenty three EVAs ( Spacewalks ) to keep upgraded and keep delivering quality images that have revolutionised our understanding of the Universe.

A comparison of the depth of vision of Hubble and James Webb Telescopes.

The 2021 launch of the James Webb Telescope has taken this understanding to a whole new level. The Telescope positioned at Lagrange Point 2 ( L2 beyond the Moon in a straight line with both the Earth and Sun ) is the spot where the gravitational pull of both Earth and Sun is at equilibrium. This allows the object to hover in an elliptical orbit around the spot. European Space Agency’s Gaia and Euclid Telescopes also occupy spots around L2.

An illustration of Lagrange Points. James Webb is at L2 along with Gaia and Eulclid telescopes. ISRO’s Aditya L1 Sun Misiion is at L1.

These telescopes are peering into the past. The Big Bang happened 13.8 billion years ago. Hubble can see a billion years into the past. The James Webb Telescope can peer over three billion years into the past, just about the time the first stars were forming.

The James Webb Telescope in its short time in space has created a stir with amazing 70mm technicolor images of our Universe. It has discovered exoplanets ( a planet outside our solar system ), has uncovered stars in previously dark areas of the sky and the latest discovery of methane and carbon dioxide on an exoplanet could point to extraterrestrial life!

In the future as technology improves we should be able to peer almost upto the Big Bang. Right now the progression of telescopes is helping mankind plug knowledge gaps that improve our understanding of the expanse.

The Space Probes

Mankind’s ambition to be Interstellar has pushed us to launch a series of probes into deep space. The earliest Pioneer 10 from 1972, entered interstellar space in 1983 followed by Pioneer 11 exited the solar system in the 1990s. These were followed by Voyager 1 and 2 entering interstellar space in 2012 and 18 respectively. The New Horizons space probe is currently in the Kuiper Belt and continuing to send fresh data back.

A schematic of the exit of the five space probes from our Solar System.

These probes are hundreds of thousands of years away from the closest celestial bodies outside the solar system and contain mankind’s attempts to communicate with extraterrestrials should they encounter any. For the immediate infinity they are coasting quietly through the expanse.

These probes launched Mankind into the Interstellar Age.

The Theory of Everything

Prof Stephen Hawking the person who directly made the concepts of the Universe available to the layman says that blackholes at the centre of all galaxies ( the Milky Way has a black hole four million times the size of the Sun ) all end in a singularity (super dense matter where the theory of relativity fails), however there are certain particles that escape the inescapable gravity and these particles create the effect of the event horizon photographed for the first time in 2019 using the event horizon telescope ( a network of telescopes across the World ). Understanding the insides of blackholes practically remains one of our biggest challenges.

Image of a black hole taken by the event event horizon telescope in 2019. The first visual of a black hole event horizon.

Time travel can be possible, but for that we need to forget Euclidean geometry the way we know it.  While we think and understand three dimensions, there is already a fourth dimension, it is time itself. Hawking believes there are upto eleven dimensions (he refers to the movie Interstellar here to help us picture how these dimensions would look) most of these dimensions might be so tiny, we neither know of them nor acknowledge them. But for true time travel to happen we need engines capable of travelling faster than the speed of light (escape velocity of Earth is 11 km/s and that of the Sun is 617 km/s, light travels at 300,000 km/s), and we need engines that can travel faster than light! Furthermore we also need the ability to bend gravity and light to open up wormholes (we do not know if they exist at the moment). So yes it’s a fantasy right now, but might be possible in the future.

Prof Hawking believed alien life forms do exist in our Universe. The odds that we are alone are stacked against us. He however felt Earth might not have contact for several decades or centuries to come, and even if we do find alien beings we should shun contact to avoid the Christopher Columbus effect on both Earth and an Alien planet. 

The Pale Blue Dot is an image of Earth taken by Voyager 1 on February, 14th 1990 taken from a distance of 6 billion kilometres. The size of earth in that image is one pixel. Astronomer Carl Sagan in his ode to that image sums up the size of the solar system as Voyager 1 was just exiting the Solar Syatem on its Interstellar journey.

Earth is the Pale Blue Dot in Voyager 1 image from February 14, 1990. Carl Sagan’s ode to this image is worth listening to. Earth is the whitish blue dot in the first band to the right of the image.

Mankind has always been interstellar by nature.

The Future

The crewed missions of the late 60s and 70s set the tone for Man to be a space traveller. However these missions, while fantastic in their achievement, lacked a broader vision and the World saw a lull for almost thirty years until the ISS once again kick started a more back to basics version of our understanding of extended travel and stays in space.

People like Elon Musk have fueled at personal expense mankind’s push to be multi planetary. Organisations such as SpaceX , NASA, European Space Agency and ISRO are conducting path breaking research on our understanding of the Moon, Mars , Sun and other planets of our solar system, in addition to creating fresh ideas and methods of rocketry.

Astounding progress in fields of robotics and Artificial Intelligence act as accelerators to the greater vision of mankind being an interstellar species.

Visionary authors like Issac Asimov and Arthur C Clarke had already painted a vision of the future over sixty years ago, we are only today achieving the first baby steps in creating this vision.

Using Schrödinger’s cat analogy , aliens both exist and don’t exist at the same time, and only once we definitively open the ET Box will mankind know for sure.

ET – I am Right Here….

Credits:

NASA

Erich Von Daniken

Christopher Dunn

Bob Lazar

Stephen Hawking

Carl Sagan

Wikipedia

Google

Washington Post

ET

The A320Neo (left) and The B737 Max (right)

October 29th, 2018 and March 10th, 2019, two dates, two crashes , one aircraft type the New B737 Max 8, one system the MCAS, 346 Souls. What happened? How did matters get to this point? Did this happen overnight? The answers to these questions find their origins 50 years ago.

In his book ‘ Hit Refresh ‘ , Satya Nadella the CEO of Microsoft coins the term ‘afragile’. His definition of the term is that in a rapidly changing and uncertain world, leaders and organisations should be agile enough to pivot and adapt to new challenges, but also open to the idea that they may make mistakes along the way. Being “fragile” in this context means acknowledging and learning from failures, using them as an opportunity for growth and improvement.

This piece tries to trace the path that led to the incidents and their aftermath, more importantly the path to the future.

Boeing and Airbus mark what is effectively a duopoly in the Global Airframe manufacturing space and dominance in the global commercial aircraft market. A competition that has driven innovation, success…. and failures.

The Background

In 2001 Boeing announced the Yellowstone Project. The ambitious project aimed at replacing their entire civilian aircraft offerings and was further broken down into three segments. The Boeing Y1 ( 100-250 passengers), the Boeing Y2 (250-350 passengers) and the Boeing Y3 (350-600+ passengers ). The Boeing Y2 be realised as the B787 Dreamliner that entered service with ANA in 2011.

The Yellowstone project aircraft comparison with existing aircraft

In direct competition to the Boeing Y2 announcement , Airbus announced the A350XWB.The 350XWB was essentially an A330 with upgraded wings and engines. However this cut little ice with Airlines already reeling under escalating oil prices. In 2004 Emirates CEO Tim Clark very publicly rebuffed Airbus for trying to sell a 20 old aircraft with neither the range, the efficiency or seating capacity up to scratch. Airbus went back to the drawing boards and pushed the A350 project back almost 9 years. When the A350 did come out the glowing reviews said it all. Today both the B787 and the A350 are mainstays of global airline fleets, their efficiencies proven.

Moral: If you fail…fail quick and cheap. In the long term game of Innovation v/s Cost, innovation generally trumps.

The Missed Opportunity

In the early 2000s Airbus had the 12 billion Euro A380 development program running. This program was launched to strengthen the needs of high density routes globally. Up until this point the Boeing 747 ‘ The Queen ‘ had ruled the skies for over 30 years. The rise of several future ‘ mega ‘ carriers had just commenced. 

There were two schools of thought. One : the mega hub model , two : the hub network model. Each has merits and demerits in the fine balance of cost v/s capacity v/s demand.

The A380 program targeted at the mega hub model, promised unheard of capacities and Y2K efficiency. Capacity starved markets salivated.

Boeing which up until that point had an almost total domination of the ‘ Jumbo Jet ‘ market had a decision on hand, develop an aircraft for this market segment  and defend the ageing B747-400 or continue with the Yellowstone projects, specifically the Boeing Y1 to replace their ageing narrow body offerings and B767. The full potential and effect of the B777 was unknown and yet to be realised. Eventually they decided to go with the B747-8, which first flew in 2010. Both the A380 and the B747-8 never achieved anything close to their promised potential and are today largely considered museum pieces, their arrivals at global airports attracting plane spotters in droves.

The wisdom of hindsight tells us, Boeing should have gone with the Y1 instead. Global Economic pressures made sure of that.

The Economic Shocks

Oil average prices per barrel on the left and percentage change of the right

Starting from the year 2000 when the average price of Oil was just over $30 a barrel upto the year 2008 when price of oil spiked sat over $145 a barrel and settled at an average cost of $99.67 a barrel, airlines had it rough. The events of 9/11 ensured the Global economy went into a shock recession, the dot com bust very real. The hooray 90s were over.

Airlines already operating on wafer thin margins ( 10% operating margin was considered a benchmark). Fuel cost accounting for approx 22% of global airline costs (the second highest cost after labour)was severely impacted by the fuel price increases. Airlines were in the ICU.

The 2008 subprime crisis further weakened airline balance sheets. The Airline Business needed a Micheal Burry to predict the storm they found themselves in.

This was the backdrop against which the airlines began clamouring for more fuel efficient planes.

Airbus responded first with the A320Neo.

The Neo Balance

In July 2011 the then American Airlines CEO Gerard Arpey announced what was called a ‘ Blockbuster Deal ‘ . Airbus won $11.5 Billion worth of orders for 260 A320neos ( the 320 family ) plus options on a further 365 aircraft of the same .

The A320 Neo

The Neo a re-engined A320 offered fuel efficiencies of upto 20% over aircraft then operating.In view of escalating fuel costs ( AA spent $500 Million more on fuel in the first quarter of 2011 than the year before ). The Neo offered efficiencies of upto 50% more than the oldest planes in the American Airlines fleet in 2011.

Boeing which won an order of 200 B737s plus options on a further 100 was left red faced as American Airlines until then had been a predominantly a Boeing customer.John Leahy the then ‘ Head of Sales ‘ at Airbus mentioned in an email , he would have been happy if Airbus sold 26 aircraft to American Airlines.

Jim Albaugh the Chief of Boeing Commercial Airplanes was forced to confront analyst suggestions Boeing’s  product strategy was in tatters. On a day when Boeing had won a $10Billion deal , they received brickbats instead of bouquets. 

The analyst community watched Boeing’s moves closely as the American order was to be followed by Delta and United later that year. Those results were a mixed bag for Boeing. Airbus was making inroads into the US aviation market.

Boeing, which lost the first mover advantage to Airbus in this market segment, proceeded to announce a re-engined B737…which would become the Max.

When announced in 2011, the required $2 Billion was yet to be approved by Boeing’s board in Chicago.

Moral: Airbus learnt it’s lessons well and heard what it’s customers needed and delivered…First

The Max

A comparison of the B727 on the left and B737 on the right

The B737 first flew in 1967, three years after the B727 that first flew in 1964.The 727 whose capacity was anywhere between 94 and 134 passengers depending on type and configuration was a trijet with amazing characteristics.

The three engines gave it additional power required to take off from short runways. The Trijet configuration set aft and high, near the tail of the aircraft allowed it to operate off gravel runways and yet avoid Foreign Object Damage(FOD). The clean wings provided for extra flaps to give the aircraft high manoeuvrability . The aircraft was set low, as a number of the airports it operated to did not have proper baggage handling facilities (it’s the 60s, remember!) and the cargo area needed to be easily accessible for baggage handlers . For airports that did not have aircraft stairs, the 727 had a ramp that dropped stairs below the tail. An amazing regional aircraft.

Boeing and the Airlines felt a need for an even smaller aircraft. Enter the 737-100. With a capacity of 85-100 passengers in a single class configuration, this was just the answer the market was looking for.

The 737 shared some design ethos as the 727 and the 707 before it. In fact all three aircraft share the same nose! There was landing gear similarity / commonality. The changes included moving the engines under the wing to maintain both aerodynamic and on ground stability. The original engines used were the JT8D-7 low bypass engines (same as the 727) and they sat under the wings with room to spare. Subsequent stretches to the Classic series continued to use the JT8D engines successfully.

When the Next Generation Series (NG) first appeared in 1984 as the B737-300 and later the 737-400, the engines had increased bypass and the front profile of the  engines now sported an oblong shape . The engines were still underwing , the changed profile characteristics improved performance and efficiency.

The NGs operated successfully and profitably for over 25 years at the time of  the American Airlines conference in 2011. 

The B737 Family’s biggest strength was cockpit commonality, a B737 type rated pilot could fly any of the aircraft. This was the first time Boeing was confronted with having to make changes so radical on the ageing airframe there would be a need for Pilot retraining.Boeing wanted to avoid this to keep retraining costs down.

The High Bypass engines ( for fuel efficiency ) were proving too big to fit under the low wing of the aircraft and the engines needed to be moved forward, this in turn would change the aerodynamic characteristics of the aircraft , which in turn needed fresh certifications . The entire B737 Max certification process came under deep scrutiny following the fatal accidents. Suffice to say the process had several conflicts of interest.

The result of the sequence of events going back over 50 years led to Boeing finding itself where it was.

Moral: Change is the only constant. Manage it with conviction and vision

The Aftermath

Post the Lion Air crash there was confusion as the flight path on Flightradar24 showed an irregular altitude and speed until the final dive at 348mph considered a high speed for an aircraft in descent. Pilots had raised multiple concerns about MCAS (Manoeuvring Characteristics and Augmentation System) the need for training and the lack of information, however all objections prior to the crash were played down.The Ethiopian aircraft flight showed a very similar path on Flightradar24 as the Lion Air crash.

Flight path comparison of the Lion Air flight on the left and Ethiopian flight on the right

Boeing continued to produce 40 aircraft a month. They did cooperate with all investigations (mostly to the point on an ask for it basis ). Grounding the aircraft was upto the Civil Aviation Authorities of  individual countries the airlines were registered in. The FAA grounded the Max three days after the second crash.

In these two battles between AI and Humans….AI won 2-0.

Monthly / Quarterly ERPs ( Emergency Response Plans ) desktop runs are standard operating procedure with most leading airlines of the World. During these desktop runs as frantic calls are simulated and normal trained airline employees man the various lines of communication (both off and online), the pressure builds quickly.

Volunteers on the frontline are rotated every 30 minutes. A visit to any leading airline’s ICC ( Incident Command Centre ) is a grim experience that sends shivers down a person’s spine as you imagine what a live situation will feel like.

Some of the crisis management training includes

  1. Every little bit of information gathering is extremely important
  2. Information can only be released once authorised by the Incident Command
  3. All speculation is to be avoided
  4. Every contact point to be handled with deep empathy and caring

Boeing was confronted by pilots , airlines, general passengers and Kin of Victims. In one particularly acrimonious meeting Boeing vice-president ( product strategy & future airplane development ) Mike Sinnett, claimed the Lion Air disaster was a once-in-a-lifetime accident.

He said: “I don’t know that understanding this system would’ve changed the outcome on this. In a million miles, you’re going to maybe fly this airplane, maybe once you’re going to see this, ever. So we try not to overload the crews with information that’s unnecessary so they actually know the information we believe is important.”

In another very public statement Boeing CEO Dennis Muilenburg declined to take any bonus for the year 2019. In 2018 He made $18 Million most of it from Bonuses, only $1.7 Million was made as salary. News such as this made Boeing look even worse as instead of showing sympathy for the victims, they came across an inward looking organisation (happens to many large organisations) that appeared out of touch with the real world. When Muilenburg did finally move out of Boeing , he did so with over $60Million in stock options. 

Boeing did settle both the legal cases, and paid almost $3 Billion in compensation ( to the best of my knowledge ).

A reference Point : On May 26th 1991 a Lauda Air 767 had an uncommanded thrust reverser deployment on a flight that had just taken off from Bangkok headed for Vienna. The deployment resulted in the B767 breaking up and crashing into a mountain side nine minutes after take off at almost the speed of sound. Niki Lauda, a motorsport legend, a pilot and the Founder of Lauda Air, went to the crash site himself and spotted the issue of the deployed reverser only on the port engine while the starboard engine appeared to be normal. Niki, who felt the full weight of 223 souls on his shoulders, took the responsibility of getting to the bottom of the disaster and took on Boeing.

While Boeing agreed off the record about the deployment, it took almost 9 months to get them to agree publicly as they feared legal liability. Suffice to say Niki the Legend prevailed.

Moral: When something’s gone wrong, admit it sincerely and correct the fault and move ahead. The general public has a very short memory.

The Recovery

Once Boeing moved past the litigations and global grounding they realised the need to move with Sincerity and Vision. They needed to acknowledge the sequence of blunders that led to this state of affairs, and acknowledge their culpability.

They needed to recover lost ground and move into confidence rebuilding mode. The Max returned to service from late 2020  after the FAA completed the recertification process. The damage to the FAA’s reputation once it came to public knowledge that both Boeing & FAA enjoyed a cosy relationship was severe and this needed to be repaired too.

While returning the aircraft back to service, Boeing had to reassure the World on multiple fronts the aircraft was safe to fly. They needed to showcase the MCAS improvements made to the pilots fraternity & of course train them, goes to say the analysts and the public were watching these developments closely. Additionally they needed to repair lost confidence with airlines, and sweet deals were the order of the day.

Boeing appears to have had seven CEOs in the last 23 years , that comes to an average of just over three years per CEO, while the average tenure of Fortune 100 companies is 7.2 years. Is the issue here? Company Culture??

The Future

A comparison of A320Neo family orders and deliveries v/s the B737 Max orders and deliveries

Current order books and deliveries show the A320Neo Family of aircraft have an advantage of over 80% v/s B737 Max orders and deliveries. This gap might only be closed with the launch of the long overdue Boeing Y1?

Boeing, a legendary company founded over 100 years ago has given several immortal aircraft to the World. Their place in the aviation hall of fame is reserved . For them to be truly ‘afragile’, they need to revisit their greatness under people like  Bill Allen, Boeing CEO between 1945 – 1968. It was under his stewardship that Boeing created several legendary aircraft including the Boeing 737. 

History is the greatest teacher and Boeing will do well to take a look at their past, as they regain lost glory. 

346 ….Afragile…..

The B737 Max

Disclaimer: The data used by the author are from open source.  

Source List:

The Seattle Times

The Guardian

Forbes

Wikipedia

Boeing & Airbus websites

For more deep dive easy to read articles please go to https://theaviationevangelist.com

Follow me:

LinkedIn : https://www.linkedin.com/company/the-aviation-evangelist/

X : @ManiRayaprolu

Reddit : r/theaviationevangelist

Last week on 9/11 eve , The authorities identified two more victims of the acts that claimed over 3000 lives. The victims identified now stand at 1649. The identifications help bring closure to two more families.

The cover of Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s book as I remember it from 2007

Nicholas Nassim Taleb in his book describes a Black Swan as a highly improbable event with three principal characteristics: It is unpredictable; it carries a massive impact; and, after the fact, we concoct an explanation that makes it appear less random, and more predictable, than it was.

While the book was more about building robustness in business to cope with such events, there has been one major change since April 2007, the book’s release. Our ability to process data has moved from the realm of reactive to the predictive. There lies the secret of our future.

The Yucatan Peninsula crater…most of it hidden underwater

The mother of Black Swan’s was the extinction level event 66 million years ago above the Yucatán peninsula. The explosion and the resulting blast crater was so vast , it remained undiscovered until the 1980s ! The discovery was possible because of the convergence of data from two unrelated fields of research. In 1979 Walter and Luis Alvarez, discovered a thin layer of clay in Gubbio, Italy that had iridium levels 160 times above the background level. It was theorized the iridium got there due to the atmospheric dissipation of the vaporized impactor . A huge crater lay waiting to be discovered.

In 1978 geophysicists Glen Penfeild and Antonio Camargo working for Pemex of Mexico were conducting an airborne magnetic survey of the Gulf of Mexico north of the Yucatán Peninsula when they discovered an anomaly 180km in diameter. 

Proving the theory right needed multiple cuts of data to match before the reason for the dinosaur extinction was proved.

The 1998 movie Deep Impact is about a comet colliding with Earth. Earth has a year and a lottery decides 200,000 Americans to shelter underground, the rest to fend for themselves. 

Extrapolating the movie and the event from 66 million years ago, there is an element of predictability that has crept in over the last 25 years. All Data driven.

In 2016 OSIRIS-REx was launched by NASA to rendezvous with Asteroid Bennu in 2018, it explored and collected samples and now returns to Earth.Such missions only plug data gaps and assist in Earth’s ability to combat previously extinction level events.

On the 22nd anniversary of 9/11 we can safely say the World is a safer due to strides made in multiple fields working in synergy. Facial and biometric recognition are widely used ( even the iPhone ). Forensic profiling has made strides in synergising nominal and criminal data to create never before observed potential criminal profiles. X-Ray machines at airports are now able to detect possible weapons both inside and outside the body without making contact. 

As our Universe gets increasingly data driven, Mankind will seek synergy with data and create a safer Earth for future generations…

Peace.

Starman in his Tesla Roadster orbiting Earth . The shot is taken within the first four hours of launch, at which time batteries ran out.

The Tesla Roadster has been in space for over five years. While it looks like the most out of this World PR stunt ever, where Elon Musk synergized both Tesla and Space X in one big flex, there are several subtle messages that allude to a much bigger vision of things to come.

The setting in the Roadster is a study by itself. Space Oddity by David Bowie is set in a loop at full volume on the sound system. A full size human mannequin was clothed in a Space X pressure spacesuit with his left arm jauntily placed on the window sill of car and the right hand on the steering wheel. A Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams in the glove box of the car along with a towel ( an essential for every space traveler ) and a 5D optical disc of Issac Asimov’s Foundation Series. The infotainment screen of the car says ‘ Don’t Panic‘.

The original single cover of Space Oddity by David Bowie

Space Oddity is an oddity in every sense and has a forgotten back story. Released on July 11th 1969 just five days before the Apollo 11 launch by a young and relatively unknown David Bowie.

The single was aimed to capitalize on the frenzy surrounding the manned Moon launch and the lyrics speak of the emotions that Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin & Micheal Collins are going through. In fact they were considered so sensitive and controversial that BBC actually banned the single until the mission was successfully completed. The rest is history. The mannequin is named after another David Bowie single ‘ Starman ‘….

The first addition cover of Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy…note the absence of Don’t Panic on the cover!
An acrylic painting of the Tesla Roadster dashboard. Note the Don’t Panic on the infotainment Screen and the mini Hotwheels Roadster between the closed AC Vents.

A Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams is prophetic in many ways, and the Roadster has tried to capture the essence of it. The story follows Arthur Dent an Englishman and the only survivor of Earth, destroyed to make way for a Hyperspace Bypass and his researcher Alien friend Ford Prefect’s many adventures as they go through the Galaxy. The Don’t Panic refers to mainly two things, one related to their ongoing adventures with surprises at every turn, two the handling of the Guide …a futuristic laptop …from 1979! In this book Earth is a Giant Super Computer ( remember Cray Super Computers !). Surprise today 44 years on we are definitely heading in that direction with the guide a combination of Laptop / Tablet / Encyclopedia / Google and of course ChatGPT! ( Remember Elon has always had reservations about AI? )

The towel in the Hitch hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy is considered an essential item for multiple reasons…the most important being a possible Moral Compass.

The Hotwheels Roadster is just a whimsy!

A 3D rendering of how the Roadster was loaded atop the second stage booster of Falcon Heavy

Issac Asimov is considered a visionary, and even today his ideas from 80 years ago sound either current current or futuristic. The Foundation series speaks of The Galactic Empire ( sound familiar? ) and mathematician Hari Seldon looking to develop a theory of psychohistory. One that combines history, sociology and mathematical statistics.

It is only today through Big Data and Machine Learning that mankind is able to combine the three and have actionable points from it….Data Science!

Overall ‘ Starman’ ploughing his lone furrow around the Sun, Earth & Mars is a harbinger of things to come in the not so distant future…the Superheavy looking to liftoff any day now points there.

The Starship almost ready to launch!
The Carriedas 160 Thumbnail picture from Flight 714 , captured in crayon by my then thirteen year old daughter…precious

The Carreidas 160 is without doubt the most famous and fabulous aircraft that never was. The actual star of Flight 714…it was not just the specs of aircraft but the paces it was put through that thrust this wonderful aircraft into the pantheon reserved for the best.

A rewind back…an impressionable eight year old had just been gifted a new comic by his Dad who had just returned from Bangalore…Flight 714….and the first thing his young eyes caught was the thumb nail…this set off a lifetime of dreaming aviation!

Back to the aircraft…a sixty year old Herge was looking to plan his next adventure…and he wanted to up the technology quotient in his comic books…however his drawing hand was not up to scratch…he enlisted Roger Leloup as his expert…Leloup’s biography says he is a technical artist and an aviation expert. Herge was known was known for the incredible amount of technical detail he put into all the machines in his comics….The moon rocket from Destination Moon…and of course ‘ The Unicorn ‘ from ‘ The Secret of the Unicorn ‘ come readily to mind…it must be said all mechanical equipment in TinTin comics was always very detailed and exacting….The Carreidas 160 ,the best of all.

Herge was also known to incorporate current events in his comics. The time that Carreidas 160 was conceptualised was the period the Concorde was under construction.

The specs are startlingly similar ( and yet different ). We start with the swing wing! Variable Geometry wings were very much in vogue in the 1960s and a number of cutting edge fighter jets. The MIG 23 ‘ Flogger ‘ and F-14 ‘ Tomcat ‘ were both in development at the same time Carriedas 160 was conceptualized.

The Carreidas 160 had three engines each developing 18,500 pounds of thrust again a very similar number of what the MiG 23 produced and about 10% less than the Tomcat ( which was much more recent ).

The glimpses of the cockpit have a very similar feel to that of the Concorde. The give away that the aircraft was designed over 60 years ago is the need for a navigator. The landing gear has a distinct look of the TSR2 again from similar vintage. The extension and compression of the gear on the landing is amazingly detailed…and possibly accurate.

The T Tail configuration appears to have been inspired by the Boeing 727. The trijet setup appears to the Trident. In fact the Trident had a T Tail too…

The cruising altitude of 40,000 feet at Mach 2. The 40,000 feet is very similar to jet aircraft of the day ex: Boeing 707, but way below Concorde’s 60,000 feet. The Mach 2 is a cruise benchmark even today.The Rolls Royce Turbomeca of the Carreidas 160 has a very similar ring to Rolls Royce Snecma engine of the Concorde.

The one weakness in the aircraft is the square windows. Leloup appears to have disregarded the DeHavilland Comet crashes of the 1950’s and instead gone with the aesthetics of square windows.

The internal aesthetics of the aircraft are of course of Biz Jet standards even today. The personal ‘ Battleship ‘ CRT a precursor of the personal entertainment on today’s jets. The fact that Lazlo Carriedas was able to see Captain Haddock’s Battleship setup points to CCTV…again cutting edge.

The fact the aircraft was able to stop on a runway a quarter the length of the runway required points to fantastic brakes! The chute deployment points to no reversers ( once again fighter jet inspiration ).

All in All the Best Aircraft that never was…

The aircraft was the true Hero of ‘ Flight 714 ‘….

Adieu….

A schematic of the Carriedas 160

Disclaimer : Pic credit the owner

The ZNMD Poster…there were multiple…all the rage of the time…

This anecdote is from twelve years ago!

Qatar Airways had launched it’s #Barcelona flights in June of 2010 , this was their second destination in Spain after #Madrid. For the first year of operations there was nothing out of the ordinary about sales from India….and suddenly around July – August 2011….there was an exponential spike in bookings! This spike continued to sustain….what was the reason? The answer lay with #ZindagiNaMilegiDobara ….#ZNMD for short….

The #bollywood blockbuster released in July 2011 and the positive effect on outbound tourism from India was almost instantaneous. So why did this happen?

The movie produced by #Excelentertainment managed to bring together the holy trinity of tourism…the tourism boards – the airlines – hotels together. The Spanish Tourism Board gave a subsidy of approx Euros 500,000 to be spent in the region and the production house did just that…the resulting showcase had a posit effect on the Indian outbound Tourism to Spain …

Movies have long been the staple of the Indian populace. Some early movies shot abroad were #LoveinTokyo and #AnEveninginParis . These movies were shot in the 1960s when the Middle Class Indian was not as mobile as today.

Of course needless to say the shooting abroad fad was taken to a whole another level by #YashChopra and his penchant for #Switzerland and #KaranJohar and his penchant for the #UnitedStates

Some of the places that have become popular with the Indian Tourist also have their origins from the Indian Film Industry. To name a few #Turkey #Azerbaijan #Armenia

Finally, the secret of successful leisure destination engineering is alliances. While there exists the Holy Trinity ( Tourism Board – Airlines – Hotels ), in some cases where the tourism boards are weaker we have Destination Management Companies stepping into the gap and doing an admirable job…goes to say nothing is possible without the Travel Agent and of course the Consumer…all working together together in harmony…

Memories

Disclaimer : All image rights belong to the owner

In Steve Jobs 2005 Stanford Commencement address, he famously mentions his tryst with Calligraphy and how it has helped shape all modern computers.

He refers to his time in Reed College where after dropping out, he decides to take a calligraphy class at the college as the beautifully calligraphed signs and labels of the entire college, that caught his eye, were infact created by the class.

Safe to say the iPad I am currently typing on was directly influenced by the class.

He uses this example when he is speaking of ‘ The Connecting the Dots Concept ‘. He further states the dots only connect towards your past and having deep faith in your focused actions will give you confidence to connect to your future and win!

Today forty years after school, I am very lucky to be in touch with a large number of my classmates …my ‘ Chuddi Buddies ‘…and have the unique opportunity of using the ‘ Steve Jobs Prism’ on the class. As in any class ,you have your first rankers and of course your back benchers…all together in this WhatsApp group aptly called ‘ Rascals of 83’…a name that will stick forever.We had students of mediocre academic ability who oozed tremendous confidence and then some who always had a clear vision of what they wanted to be and some…like me who really had no concept of a vision and fell into the mediocre category.

So what happens when you develop a strong sense of vision? Even students of mediocre ability begin to achieve goals. The Rascals of 83 group is full of such successes. And there are some students who were anointed toward success at a very young age. None disappointed. I now realize the absence of a clear vision actually helped in my performance toward mediocrity!

The difference between a Dream and Vision is a series of implementation steps and milestones. Each step and milestone passed only increases your self confidence and propels you forward and upward…

To sum up…Calligraph your own success with your self belief and it will be yours!

Cheers!

In Grapevine just off TX 121 is Founders Plaza. The plaza is an observation gallery on the North East End of the runways and has a special tug to all avgeeks…

Obviously it is the close proximity to the modern miracles called Aircraft , but there is something else.

The Observatory is a memorial, a place of celebration and a place of freedom.

The Memorial

The Foundation Stone

The Founders plaza Foundation stone .

The Foundation stone. Notice the awning right behind for plane spotters / picnickers to settle down for a session of plane spotting

Directly to the front of the Foundation stone is a sculpture that is the personification of freedom.

To the left of the Foundation Stone is the Braniff International Plaque.

The Hero’s Fountain

The Foundation is directly opposite the foundation stone and behind the sculpture. It’s in a centre circle …cars drive around teh circle and park.

The broader scene

The place always has space for plane lovers…except in July 2022 when British Airways relaunched it’s A380 operation from LHR to DFW…that afternoon over 2000 plane spotters descended on the place. It was a regular traffic jam!

Views of aircraft landing from both North & South.

A Qatar Airways A350 on short finals …the North End
A British Airways A380 just landed from the South end and taxiing towards Terminal D
The UPS Hangers right next to the AA Hangers just off Founders Plaza

With so much inspiration around, makes you wonder how many young avgeeks / airline personnel were inspired to take up the job by this very spot?

The spot begs plane lovers to keep visiting…

An Oasis of Tranquility….

Prologue

Living in the shadow of one of the busiest airports in the World, the sky above us is always full of aircraft either on short finals or taking off from DFW Airport. 

I am suddenly struck by what I have been seeing, all the aircraft almost without fail are twin engined ops and most have been around for decades

A comparison of the largest selling airliners..yes the 747 is not on it!

The above table clearly conveys most of the aircraft flying today are actually 40 year old airframe designs with improvements made in the direction of efficiency.

Wing Design

The biggest enemy of an aircraft is drag. Traditional wing design has always caused a lot of turbulence at the wing tips. There has been considerable time money and energy spent to improve existing wing performance with all new wings that incorporate the winglet / sharklet.

Winglet types flying today

*image credit AME Question Paper via Google

Another area of tremendous improvement is the engines. What were previously noisy and smoky affairs are now almost quiet and smokeless. Almost all civilian passenger aircraft today use high bypass engines.

A comparison of bypass engine types . High Bypass was invented in the mid 1960s

*image credit Wikipedia

The Race

From the early 1900s through to the 1980s it was an era of constantly breaking fresh ground. The image below shows the speed race over before 1980…set by the fabled Lockheed SR-71….Same goes for height.

The flight speed record progression…nothing new since the late 1970s

*image credit Wikipedia

The B747 ( The Queen of the Skies ) and the legendary Concorde both had their first flight within a month of each other in February ( B747 ) and March ( Concorde ) of 1969. These two aircraft represented two different approaches to way passengers fly. Both marvels ahead of their time and both endure as freighters or museum pieces.

A tale of two BA Queens…

*image credit Quora / Google / creator

The B747 has written it’s own fantastic story over 54 years and is continuing to fly among the global fleet today, it’s Concorde that was jinx from the beginning.

The Concorde

From the moment the development project was announced in 1962 the Concorde has been the centre of controversy. Whether it was it’s highly noisy and smoky Snecma Olympus Engines or it’s sonic boom.

From over 100 orders to the final 14 sold to just two operators ( British Airways & Air France ) the national airlines of the countries that supported their development ( UK & France ).

What should have been a singular triumph ( in some ways it still is ) became an elitist way of travel and was ultimately restricted to just the scheduled routes of London / Paris – New York ( v v ). When Concorde was finally de registered ( grounded ) in 2003 the average number of cycles on each Concorde was only around 5000 cycles. The number an average B747 hit in about 5-7 years.

Today  when we see them as museum pieces, we envision engineering at it’s best and can only imagine the Champagne based conversations on board.

Enter BOOM

BOOM’s big idea is to democratize Supersonic travel and towards that end they are engineering a completely new aircraft ( the basics don’t change )

Concorde / Overture comparison

The numbers speak a very familiar story. The big difference being weight. Advances in composite materials make the the Overture fast and at the same time very light. With 35 confirmed orders from United Airlines & American and multiple airlines showing interest. This might yet be the dawn of the second Supersonic age in passenger travel.

Points to mention

  • BOOM Symphony engines will use only SAF ( Sustainable Aviation Fuel )
  • The increased range gives it reach where Concorde missed out..also makes a case for even more increased range
  • The Tourism market is completely different now what it was in 2003 when Concorde retired and this can be a huge difference ( Ex : In 2000 there were only 470 billionaires in the World and today we have almost 2500 , this highlights the GDP growth and growing incomes globally to afford what could be the equivalent of a First Class ticket)
  • A clear focus on the environment across all parameters takes out all the opposition that Concorde had
  • With over 35 orders firmed up most of them from United and American maybe it’s the dawn of the Supersonic age on Commercial America Aviation

What we see is the world was not ready for Concorde and when the BOOM – Overture flies…will be welcomed with open arms!

The development of the Overture can spawn a completely fresh direction in passenger travel. This is why projects such as this are important.

Go BOOM!!

You are fresh out of University and looking for a fresh role in Commercial…what do you do? When in doubt, always start with the Basics!

The P.E.S.T Analysis

In the absence of access to any historical data, this is always a great place to start. P.E.S.T is an acronym for Political / Economic / Social / Technology…every aspect of our lives is impacted by one of these four segments.

Examples:

  • Political : Ukraine was a country that had a thriving Tourism Industry however the ongoing war has impacted the industry.
  • Economic : India as a country has a GDP growth of approx 6.1% this automatically will see a rise in air travel both corporate and leisure, and sale of smart phones
  • Social : The DFW Metroplex area has seen a population growth from 4,000,000 to 8,000,000 over the last thirty year, this will automatically take real estate values up and there should be plenty of teaching position available
  • Technology : The advent of Data usage has changed sales jobs from being pure sales to that of Business Development and a Data Analyst

From the above examples we can draw conclusions based on the Macro conditions of whatever it is you are trying to research

Organizational Research

Before you go into an interview ensure you know everything there is to know about the company on the internet. Excellent starting points:

  • The annual reports are excellent places to start for listed companies. Here you not only have a clear pictures of the company’s P & L but also their guidance over the next 18 to 24 months. This is excellent ammunition to have, especially when you are up against a panel and questions can come thick and fast
  • The S.W.O.T Analysis. This will give you a competitive understanding of the organization viz a viz competition, this in conjunction with the P.E.S.T Analysis & Annual Reports should give you a deep understanding of what to expect with the company ( growth wise )

You the Person

  • It is important you visualize yourself with the company as you do the above analysis. This way you have already imbibed a number of the qualities the company is looking for
  • Exhibit your knowledge to the interviewer…but be understated. The company needs you as much as you need it
  • Always be professionally attired ( even for phone interviews )

The Final Word

Job Searches can be long and arduous and be demotivating, it’s at times like this you show off your resilience and tenacity.

Best of Luck!